See important information in relation to COVID-19 and our services here

Primary Care Appeals decisions

We publish up to three years’ worth of decisions on appeals and disputes here.

Please note that in order to find a relevant decision for a particular application type users should enter specific wording rather than the regulation number.  For example “Current Need” for regulation 13 or “Unforeseen Benefit” for regulation 18.

If you would like to see any of the past decisions that are not available on the website, please email us at nhsr.appeals@nhs.net.

24691: Application to relocate a pharmacy in Ipswich

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) Area: NHS England - Midlands & East (East)

Decision making body: NHS England Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Avalake Ltd T/A Wellbeing Pharmacy

By application dated 3 September 2021, Avalake Ltd T/A Wellbeing Pharmacy (“the Applicant”) applied to NHS Commissioning Board (“NHS England”) for a relocation that does not result in a significant change to pharmaceutical services provision under Regulation 24 from 29 Chesterfield Drive, Ipswich, IP1 6DW to The New Health Centre, Old Norwich Road, Ipswich, IP1 6LD.

24696: Appeal regarding direction to open

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) Area: NHS England - South (South West)

Decision making body: NHS England Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Boots UK Ltd

Relying on Paragraph 25 of Schedule 4, NHS England has requested that the Appellant open from 13:00 – 15:00 on 17 April 2022

24675: Application to open a distance selling pharmacy in Cleethorpes

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) Area: NHS England - North (Yorkshire & the Humber)

Decision making body: NHS England Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Karma Medical Solutions Ltd

By application dated 24 April 2021, Karma Medical Solutions Limited (“the Applicant”) applied to NHS Commissioning Board (“NHS England”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list at 55 Grimsby Road, Cleethorpes, North East Lincolnshire, DN35 7AF under Regulation 25.

24673: Dispute regarding childhood immunisation payments

Function: Medical Area: NHS England - North (Yorkshire & the Humber)

Decision making body: NHS England GMS contractor: King Cross Surgery

The Contractor referred the dispute in relation to its General Medical Services Contract for dispute resolution under the provisions of paragraph 99 of Schedule 6 of the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015 (the “Regulations”).

24615: Dispute regarding contractual overpayments

Function: Medical Area: NHS England - North (Greater Manchester)

Decision making body: NHS England PMS contractor: Drs Stockton and Thompson

NHS England has referred to NHS Resolution the dispute in relation to the Personal Medical Services Agreement for dispute resolution under Paragraph 76 of the NHS (Personal Medical Services Agreement) Regulations 2015 (“the Regulations”).

24668: Dispute regarding Covid-19 vaccination programme

Function: Medical Area: NHS England - Midlands & East (Central Midlands)

Decision making body: NHS England GMS contractor: Theomed Limited

Herts Valley CCG (“the CCG”) on behalf of NHS England has referred the matter in relation to the Contractor’s General Medical Services (“GMS”) Contract for dispute resolution under the provisions of paragraph 99 of Schedule 6 of the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015 (the “Regulations”).

24638: Dispute regarding current market rent

Function: Medical Area: NHS England - London (North Central & East)

Decision making body: NHS England PMS contractor: Dr Savage & Partners

The Contractor has referred the dispute in relation to its Personal Medical Services Agreement for dispute resolution under Paragraph 76 Schedule 5 of the NHS (Personal Medical Services Agreement) Regulations 2015 (“the Regulations”). The Contractor’s PMS Agreement indicates a commencement date of 1 October 2017 and I therefore consider that the 2015 Regulations apply to this dispute.

24693: Appeal against pharmacy directed opening

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) Area: NHS England - Midlands & East (North Midlands)

Decision making body: NHS England Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): PCT Healthcare Ltd t/a Peak Pharmacy

Relying on Paragraph 25 of Schedule 4, NHS England has requested that the Appellant open from 10am to 12noon on Sunday 17 April 2022.