Primary Care Appeals decisions

We publish up to three years’ worth of decisions on appeals and disputes here.

Please note that in order to find a relevant decision for a particular application type users should enter specific wording rather than the regulation number.  For example “Current Need” for regulation 13 or “Unforeseen Benefit” for regulation 18.

If you would like to see any of the past decisions that are not available on the website, please email us at nhsr.appeals@nhs.net.

26163: Application to open a pharmacy in Loughborough

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Kings Pharmacy Ltd

By application dated 20 May 2023, Kings Pharmacy Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland ICB (“the Commissioner”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list at 146 King Street, Loughborough LE11 1SD under Regulation 25.

26207: Appeal against refusal of third party appeal rights

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: South East

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): MC Shirley Limited

By application dated 18 October 2023, MC Shirley Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to the Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB (“the Commissioner”) for a no significant change relocation from 17 Grove Road, Shirley, Southampton, SO15 3HH to 302 Shirley Road, Shirley, Southampton, SO15 3HL

26159: Application to change pharmacy opening hours

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Repeat Prescription Order Line Limited

The Applicant has applied to the Commissioner to change the days and times at which it is obliged to provide pharmaceutical services at the above premises. The Applicant seeks to keep the total number of core opening hours the same while offering a different distribution of these hours during the week.

26176: Appeal against breach notice

Function: Pharmaceutical performance related sanctions ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (sanction): Mansfield Woodhouse Pharmacy

A Breach Notice dated 23 February 2024 was sent to Mansfield Woodhouse Pharmacy (“the Appellant”) in respect of 12 High Street, Mansfield Woodhouse, Nottinghamshire NG19 8AN.

26156: Pharmacy consolidation application in Birmingham

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Pan Healthcare Limited t/a Pan Pharmacy

By application dated 26 July 2023, Pan Healthcare Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Birmingham and Solihull ICB (“the Commissioner”) in respect of a consolidation onto the site at 2154A – 2156 Coventry Road, Sheldon, Birmingham, B26 3JB, of Pan Pharmacy already at that site and Pan Pharmacy currently at 2222 Coventry Road, Sheldon, Birmingham, B26 3JH. The application was made pursuant to Regulation 26A of the National Health Service (Pharmaceutical and Local Pharmaceutical Services) Regulations 2013 (“the Regulations”).

26169: Dispute regarding influenza vaccination payments

Function: Medical ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB GMS contractor: Kingstanding Circle Surgery

The Contractor referred the dispute in relation to its General Medical Services Contract for dispute resolution under the provisions of Regulation 83 of the National Health Service (General Medical Services Contracts) Regulations 2015 (the “Regulations”).

26162: Application to open a pharmacy in Bracknell

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: London

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Zinbake Limited

By application dated 27 April 2023, Zinbake Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Frimley ICB (“the Commissioner”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list offering unforeseen benefits under Regulation 18 at Crown Row, Crown Wood, Bracknell, Berkshire, RG12 0TH .