Freedom of Information disclosure log

Clinical scheme for GPs (FOI_6120)

The following information was requested:

In each of the NHSR accounting years 2019/20, 2020/21, 2021/22 and 2022/23, in respect of all clinical schemes for GPs please provide the following information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

1. The number of clinical negligence claims received during the year.
2. The number of clinical negligence claims closed during the year.
3. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
4. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
5. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
a. The total damages paid.
b. The total Claimant costs.
c. The total Defendant costs.
6. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
b. The total damages paid.
c. The total Claimant costs.
d. The Total Defendant costs.
7. In respect of the Claims identified in 4, please state:
a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
b. The total damages paid.
c. The total Claimant costs.
d. The total Defendant costs.
8. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
9. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
10. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
a. The total damages paid
b. The total Claimant costs
c. The total Defendant costs
11. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
b. The total damages paid.
c. The total Claimant costs.
d. The total Defendant costs.
12. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
b. The total damages paid.
c. The total Claimant costs.
d. The total Defendant costs.

Cauda Equina Syndrome (FOI_6110)

The following information was requested:

RE: Litigation in cauda equina syndrome cases (CES) – up to date figures

I have been searching for up-to-date figures relating to litigation in CES nationally… but the most recent I can find via Google are from 2018.

I am keen to know:
– Number of claims/cases per year related to diagnosis or treatment of CES;
– Average payout for settlements or litigation related to CES cases for a year closer to 2023.

Are these figures you can provide?

Clinical Claims and costs (FOI_6112)

The following information was requested:

In each of the NHSR accounting years 2018/19, 2019/20, 2020/21, 2021/22 and 2021/23, in respect of all clinical negligence schemes;

  1. The number of clinical negligence claims received during the year.
  2. The number of clinical negligence claims closed during the year.
  3. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
  4. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
  5. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The total damages paid.
    b. The total Claimant costs.
    c. The total Defendant costs.
  6. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The Total Defendant costs.
  7. In respect of the Claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.
  8. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
  9. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
  10. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The total damages paid
    b. The total Claimant costs
    c. The total Defendant costs
  11. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.
  12. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.

Clinical negligence claims for private healthcare provider (FOI_6113)

The following information was requested:

In each of the NHSR accounting years 2018/19, 2019/20, 2020/21, 2021/22 and 2022/23, in respect of all claims where the treatment giving rise to the claim was provided by a private healthcare provider with the indemnity provided under one of the clinical negligence schemes, please provide the following information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

  1. The number of clinical negligence claims received during the year.
  2. The number of clinical negligence claims closed during the year.
  3. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
  4. The number of clinical negligence claims closed before the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
  5. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The total damages paid.
    b. The total Claimant costs.
    c. The total Defendant costs.
  6. In respect of the claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The Total Defendant costs.
  7. In respect of the Claims identified in 4, please state:
    a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.
  8. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with no payment of damages.
  9. The number of clinical negligence claims closed after the issue of proceedings with payment of damages.
  10. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The total damages paid
    b. The total Claimant costs
    c. The total Defendant costs
  11. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The number of claims where the damages did not exceed £25,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.
  12. In respect of the claims identified in 9, please state
    a. The number of claims where the damages exceeded £25,000 but did not exceed £100,000 and in respect of those cases:
    b. The total damages paid.
    c. The total Claimant costs.
    d. The total Defendant costs.

Top 20 highest paid claimant firms (FOI_6114)

The following information was requested:

NHSR previously provided the following: FOI_5534 which covered:

Claimant legal costs for clinical negligence claims, broken down by the top 20 claimant firms, and the number of claims these costs relate to.

Could you now please provide the equivalent information for the financial year 2022/23.

Delayed arrival of an ambulance (FOI_6109)

The following information was requested:

  1. In each of the last five financial years (2017/18) (2018/19) (2019/20)(2021/22) and (2022/23) please state how many claims has the NHS Resolution paid out where the cause of the claim has been the delayed arrival of an ambulance?
  2. As well as the number of successful claims in each year please state for each year the (i) total compensation paid to claimants, (ii) the legal costs paid to claimants, (iii) the defence costs incurred by NHS Resolution and (iv) the total cost of these successful claims.
  3. For the combined five years please provide a table showing the injury codes that the claims were allocated to and the total amount of compensation for those successful claims.

Vaginal Mesh claims against Torbay and South Devon NHS FT (FOI_6106)

The following information was requested:

  1. What was the total number of allegations or attempted clinical negligence claims related to surgical TVT/TAT mesh against Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust per annum since 2006? Please provide the data broken down by year.
  2. What was the total number of successful clinical negligence claims related to surgical TVT/TAT mesh against Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust per annum since 2006? Please provide the data broken down by year.
  3. What was the total sum paid out in successful and settled clinical negligence claims related to surgical TVT/TAT mesh against Torbay and South Devon NHS Foundation Trust per annum since 2006? Please provide the data broken down by year.

Awards and accreditation badges