Primary Care Appeals decisions

We publish up to three years’ worth of decisions on appeals and disputes here.

Please note that in order to find a relevant decision for a particular application type users should enter specific wording rather than the regulation number.  For example “Current Need” for regulation 13 or “Unforeseen Benefit” for regulation 18.

If you would like to see any of the past decisions that are not available on the website, please email us at nhsr.appeals@nhs.net.

SHA/26794: Application to open a pharmacy in Borehamwood

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: East of England

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Organ Hall Pharma Ltd

By application dated 4 June 2026, Organ Hall Pharma Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Hertfordshire and West Essex ICB (“the Commissioner”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list offering unforeseen benefits under Regulation 18 at New Medical Centre, Borehamwood, WD6 4DG.

SHA/26799: Application for a pharmacy change of ownership

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: Midlands

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Ethel Road Healthcare Ltd

By application dated 7 June 2025, Ethel Road Healthcare Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland ICB (“the Commissioner”) for a change of ownership from Imaan Ltd in respect of 174 Ethel Road, Leicester, LE5 4WE.

SHA/26801: Application to open a pharmacy in Gillingham

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: South West

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Kingston Pharma Ltd

By application dated 21 June 2025, Kingston Pharma Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Dorset ICB (“the Commissioner”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list at 16 Broad Robin, Gillingham, SP8 4PJ under Regulation 25.

SHA/26893: Application to relocate a pharmacy in Hull (third party appeal rights)

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: North East and Yorkshire

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Sutton Manor Pharma Services

By application dated 26 September 2025, Sutton Manor Pharma Services Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to the Humber and North Yorkshire ICB (“the Commissioner”) for a no significant change relocation from 633 Anlaby Road, Hull, HU3 6SX TO 61 Calvert Lane, Hull, HU4 6BL.

SHA/26929: Application to relocate a pharmacy in Hull

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: North East and Yorkshire

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Sutton Manor Pharma Services Limited

By application dated 26 September 2025, Sutton Manor Pharma Services Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to the Humber and North Yorkshire ICB (“the Commissioner”) for a no significant change relocation from 633 Anlaby Road, Hull, HU3 6SX TO 61 Calvert Lane, Hull, HU4 6BL.

SHA/26782: Appeal regarding suspension payments

Function: Performers list management ICS/ICBS Region: North West

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB

The above named Appellant has referred the matter for consideration under the National Health Service (Performers Lists) (England) Regulations 2013 (“the Regulations”).

SHA/26797: Application to open a pharmacy in Preston

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: North West

Decision making body: NHS England/ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): AYP Healthcare Ltd

By application dated 17 June 2025, AYP Healthcare Ltd (“the Applicant”) applied to Lancashire and South Cumbria ICB (“the Commissioner”) for inclusion in the pharmaceutical list at 160-164 Lancaster Road North, Preston, PR1 2PZ under Regulation 25.

SHA/26770: Application to change pharmacy opening hours

Function: Pharmaceutical (under 2012 & 2013 regulations) ICS/ICBS Region: North East and Yorkshire

Decision making body: ICB Pharmaceutical contractor (entry): Stone Pharmacy

The Applicant has applied to the Commissioner to change the days and times at which it is obliged to provide pharmaceutical services at the above premises. The Applicant seeks to keep the total number of core opening hours the same while offering a different distribution of these hours during the week.

Awards and accreditation badges